I talk to people every day who have unreasonable expectations of their WiFi connectivity, especially when connecting to public networks. I’d like to take a minute to explain the limits of WiFi in public hotspots. Please note that a lot of the points in this article do not apply to home WiFi routers.
1: The “F” in WiFi does not mean “Free”.
If I had a nickel for every time someone insisted that “WiFi” means “Wireles Internet, Free internet,” I’d need help lifting my huge bag of nickels.
“WiFi” is a play on the term “HiFi,” which means “High Fidelity” and applies to audio recording technology. While some free public WiFi networks do exist, there are a large number of paid services available in coffee shops, airports, hotels and other places.
You have to pay for internet at home — is it really so unbelievable that you’d have to pay for it elsewhere?
2: The maximum reach of 802.11g WiFi is 300 feet.
That’s 300 feet outdoors, with no interference. For indoor access points, the recognized average is 120 feet. If you live next door to a coffee shop that provides WiFi, chances are that there’s too much steel, wood, concrete, insulation and drywall between you and the wireless router for you to get a reliable signal.
Furthermore, the wireless antenna built into your laptop is not very powerful. You can use a utility like Netstumbler to survey the wireless networks available to you, and assess what signal strength and quality you can expect to receive from them.
Generally speaking, if you’re looking to receive WiFi in your home, you’re going to have to get a cable or DSL connection and set up a wireless router. With the exception of a few cities that provide municipal WiFi networks, WiFi is not something that you can receive in your home from an outside source; and the municipal networks can be sketchy — I don’t recommend them.
3: Almost everything interferes with WiFi.
WiFi operates at 2.4 GHz — just like most cordless phones, Bluetooth, some RF signals, and a host of other electronic communications devices.
WiFi will go through one or two walls without much degradation, but it can be interrupted by microwaves, CRT televisions, reflective surfaces, other computers using WiFi, other WiFi signals broadcast on the same channel… the list goes on.
This shouldn’t dissuade you from using WiFi altogether! If you have a wireless router in your house, you’ll probably get great reception from it — WiFi is primarily intended for short-range, single-building connectivity. It is possible to stretch it farther with high-gain equipment, but that can become costly (and if you’re going to shell out the money, why not get a cable or DSL connection instead?).
4: Business Class service for your business.
There is a reason that businesses pay extra for business class service. Business class connections come with things like guaranteed uptime and redundant circuits — ISPs prioritize outages for business class customers, and have extra measures in place to meet their needs.
Basically, you may be able to run your business on residential service or public WiFi if you require intermittent connectivity to the internet; but if the possibility of 3-5 days’ downtime would cripple your business or shut you down completely, you need business class.
5: Free WiFi in apartment complexes is worth every penny.
If you’re moving into a new apartment and the offer Free WiFi, be suspicious. Depending on which apartment you get, the signal may not reach into your unit very well. You may have to sit on your patio to get online. For the amount that they add to your rent, you could probably get a DSL connection of your own.
Furthermore, even if you get a good signal and the hotspot equipment is working fine, the bandwidth available to the service is split between everybody who’s using it; and if one of your fellow tenants is downloading torrents with wild abandon, it can severely slow down your connection — or worse, the management might have opted for a low-bandwidth plan, or may be blocking some ports or services.
If you’re considering an apartment with free WiFi, at least ask questions:
- How much total bandwidth is available?
- Is there a cap on my bandwidth or usage?
- Are any sites/ports/services blocked?
- Who provides the service, and do they offer competent technical support?
- Can I opt out?
Whether you can opt out or not, you should still be able to get your own DSL or cable connection. Make sure you know all of your options.
6: All connections are NOT created equal.
While a WiFi connection may be suitable for checking your email or looking up movie times, if you’re trying to stream HD video, be prepared for disappointment. No WiFi provider is going to guarantee any minimum level of bandwidth or speed.
Of course, this doesn’t necessarily apply to the wireless router in your house running on your cable or DSL connection; this unobstructed, unshared signal can be just as reliable as plugging a cable directly from the modem into your computer.
7: Bandwidth vs. WiFi transfer rate
802.11g has a maximum transfer rate of 54 Mb per second. That’s megabits, not megabytes — there are 8 bits in a byte, so wireless-G is capable of transferring up to 7 MB per second. The newest standard, 802.11n, doubles that: 108Mb/14MB per second, under optimal conditions.
This does NOT mean that you’ll be able to download at this rate. A standard DSL connection will run anywhere from 3-7 Mbps, so you can download from a website at almost 1MB per second (optimally). Cable connections typically run from 5-15 Mbps, so you may be able to get close to 2MB per second from the web — assuming, of course, that the web server from which you’re downloading makes that speed available to you.
In short, a 54 Mbps WiFi connection should not lead you to believe that you can download a 1-gigabyte file in under a minute. Remember:
- Know the difference between bits and bytes
- Your router’s transfer rate is limited by your connection’s bandwidth
- Your download rate may be capped by the server providing the files
Public WiFi is great for checking your email or looking up web pages, but it’s not reliable as a constant connection. The best description of the service you’ll get? Results May Vary.
We provide wifi to apartment complexes. Our wireless is no different than a dsl connection would be to the end user. We use 100Mb internet circuits. Every user is assigned a public IP and traffic is managed on a per user basis. We are not the only ones doing this. To knock wifi in general is just bogus. It is simply a delivery mechanism. ADSL2 provides 24Mbps, we can provide far more than this if a subscriber wishes to pay for it.
Unless you’re placing a WAP in each unit, your deployment cannot offer the same connectivity that a cable/DSL connection can. The walls of the complex can cause interference. If one or two people in the complex are avid file-sharers, the number of open IP connections they can generate can choke the bandwidth for everyone else (unless you cap bandwidth per user, of course).
How many users do you have? There’s usually a fairly high level of expense involved in purchasing a block of public IPs large enough to provide public IP addresses to an entire apartment complex. What’s the end cost per user for that? Can you explain how “traffic is managed on a per user basis”? It sounds like you’re just describing how DHCP works, and presenting it as a value-added service.
I’m not knocking WiFi in general. If you read the article, you’ll see several admonitions such as “If you have a wireless router in your house, you’ll probably get great reception from it”.
100Mb internet circuits are standard ethernet lines — though it’s become common practice to use gigabit ethernet in new deployments. Is your ISP providing 100Mb of bandwidth to the incoming connection? If not, you’re only talking about the maximum transfer rate of the lines used in the building. 802.11g WAPs have a maximum transfer rate of 54Mb, and that bandwidth is shared among all of the users connected. Insinuating that you’re offering your users 100Mb of bandwidth is “bogus”.
A responsible provider of WiFi in public deployments would never guarantee specific levels of uptime or available bandwidth. You cannot manage or account for all of the potential sources of interference.